The short story format is probably one of the hardest to write well. There are some authors who do short stories beautifully (Joe Hill, Stephen King, Clive Barker for example). For me, the short story format sounds like a great idea. I have an idea for a story, I feel it’ll be an interesting little adventure for an afternoon read, and before I know it I’m 30,000 words into a novella or novel that I have no idea how it’ll end.
At least, that was how things went for me before I started writing outlines. Over the course of about ten years of practicing telling myself stories I’ve come to believe very deeply in Michael Crichton’s statement (https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/57327-books-aren-t-written—they-re-rewritten-including-your-own-it) stories “aren’t written, they’re re-written.” This is true, and I’m sure even the best author in the world has phrases or scenes she wishes she could revise just once more to edit out that one word that doesn’t quite fit.
I started outlining because I wanted to write the ending of a story, but in order to get to that ending, I had to know how the ending came about. So I started writing outlines to tell myself the story from a high level. Then I began filling in the details of each outline, filling in each scene, again at a high level, and telling the story again. Then I told the story to myself again, this time adding more detail like people’s names, scene descriptions, lines of dialogue, until it became a really detailed map of the story, showing step by step how to get to the ending I wanted. Only then did I feel I was ready to begin writing.
The outlining process helped me take a good idea and turn it into good execution. Sometimes the stories are more successful than I expected, sometimes they take much more work than I had hoped. Either way, if I start writing an outline, I get a finished story instead of a story that starts off well but goes nowhere.
In a later article I’ll write about the software I use to write everything (including these blog articles).